The Past Is a Very Good Place to Hide Something New
A car company and a government both rebranded this month by looking backwards. That timing is no accident.
Two rebrands, one direction
Within about a week of each other, a car company and a government both rebranded, and both did it by looking backwards.
Last week McLaren unveiled a new wordmark based on the hand-painted sign that hung above the service station Bruce McLaren's parents ran in Remuera, Auckland, the garage where he built his first winning race car. It replaces lettering that had been in use since 1981, and the coverage was warm in a way rebrands rarely enjoy, full of founders and family businesses and old photographs. A few paragraphs further down most of those articles, though, was the other piece of news, which is that McLaren is building its first SUV.
That timing is no accident, and I think it's good work. A supercar maker launching a family car is precisely the kind of change that makes loyal customers nervous, so McLaren reached back to 1920s Auckland and presented the whole thing as a homecoming. The new direction arrives wearing the clothes of the old one, and it's much harder to feel betrayed by something that looks like where you came in.
A rebrand with no logo
Labour has been doing something similar, only without touching the logo at all. Andy Burnham is the country's seventh prime minister since 2016 and the second Labour one in two years, and when he took over in July he promised people a return to the Labour they once knew. There's no new rose and no new typeface, because the rebrand is entirely in the story, and the story points backwards.
What makes it clever is that he never says which Labour he means. It could be 1945, or 1997, or whichever version your parents voted for, and every listener simply fills in that gap with their own memory. A memory you've supplied yourself is a very difficult thing to argue with. Every party reaches for the past when it needs trust in a hurry, of course, and the Conservatives, who supplied five of those seven prime ministers, have it written into their name.
Why it works
People feel a loss far more sharply than they feel a gain of the same size, and almost any change registers as a loss before it registers as anything else. Nostalgia turns that around by recasting the new thing as a return, so that the risky option begins to feel like the familiar one. An SUV from the garage in Auckland feels less like McLaren abandoning what it stood for, and a second Labour leader in two years feels less like a party that couldn't make its mind up. Great British Railways has used the same move from the other direction, bringing back the double arrow British Rail first used in 1965 so that a brand-new organisation could borrow sixty years of credibility on its first day.
The risk runs both ways. When Cracker Barrel took the old man and his barrel out of its logo in August 2025, the share price fell, the internet revolted, and the old man was back within a week. Your history doesn't entirely belong to you. Your customers have been carrying it around for years, and they'll defend it with more energy than you might expect.
The catch
Nostalgia buys you a hearing, but it doesn't buy you a verdict. McLaren still has to build an SUV that people actually want to own, and Labour's first Budget arrives on 28 October, when voters will start checking whether anything has changed besides the tone of voice. The sign above the garage only earns its place if what happens inside the garage lives up to it.
What this means for your business
If you've been trading for twenty or thirty years, you have a past worth using, and most of the established businesses we rebrand are hiding theirs. The founder's first van, the original premises and the reason the whole thing started tend to be buried somewhere beneath stock photography and the word "solutions", when they're often the most persuasive thing the business owns. It's one of the clearest signs that a business has got better while its brand stood still. So find the sign above your garage, and use it to make your next change believable rather than as a reason to avoid changing at all.
Your history is probably the most convincing thing you own. It seems a shame to keep it in a drawer.
More insights
All insightsWe Will Miss the ChatGPT Flyer
People are properly annoyed about AI posters made by small businesses. For thirty years the alternative was Comic Sans on a sheet of A4, and nobody minded that.
We Outgrew Ours Too
We spend most of our time telling businesses they've outgrown how they look. It's a strange feeling when it's your turn.
Nobody Decides to Go Off-Brand
Every brand drifts a little each time somebody needs a post by four o'clock, and AI has made four o'clock come round a lot more often.