Is the Medium Still the Message?

The comfortable answer is yes, but is it correct?

Is the Medium Still the Message?

The comfortable answer is yes.

Marshall McLuhan said it in the 1960s. "The medium is the message" it's not what you're reading, it's how you're reading it. Not the content, but the form, the form reshapes you.

Apply that logic to AI and everything feels fine. AI is just another medium shift, like radio replacing print, television replacing radio, the internet replacing television. Different form, same principle. The medium (algorithmic curation, personalised feeds, generative tools) becomes the message. We adapt because we always do, right?

The Case That McLuhan Was Right

There's a strong intellectual case for this. Contemporary media scholars argue that AI, as a medium, fundamentally alters human perception and social structures, exactly as McLuhan predicted.

The medium of algorithmic curation shapes what you see and how you engage with it. Real-time personalisation changes your relationship to information. Generative tools like ChatGPT, Midjourney et al aren't just tools, they're environments; they reshape how we think about creativity, authorship, meaning itself.

By this logic, AI as a medium extends human cognition the way the telephone extended the voice or the printing press extended thought. I don't think it's making us stupid, but it's definitely making us different. It's changing the shape of the questions we ask.

It's a respectable position, Grant Havers, in his recent book "The Medium Is Still the Message: Marshall McLuhan for Our Time," argues that McLuhan's 1960s insight remains the indispensable framework for understanding technology today. The form matters more than the content, the environment shapes the inhabitant, not the other way around.

Except There's a Problem

McLuhan never encountered a medium that created and curated simultaneously. Radio was a medium, but radio stations employed humans to generate content. Television was a medium, they too hired directors, writers, actors. The internet decentralised publishing, but we (the meaty robots) still wrote the things being published. In every case, there was a separation. One entity created, the other distributed. One was human, one was mechanical.

AI muddies that water significantly.

The same algorithms that decide what you see can now generate what there is to see. It can create variations, tests them and iterates on them. All without a human being present and all optimising for a single metric: engagement.

This difference matters enough that a growing body of scholarship argues McLuhan's framework doesn't quite fit. A 2025 literature review from the Preprints archive argues that while McLuhan provides foundational insights, his theories "underestimate media that exhibit agency-like qualities, such as AI systems that generate, filter, and dynamically modify content."

Unlike passive media, AI actively participates in meaning-making. It's not just a medium anymore, it's a co-creator.

Why This Distinction Matters

When you have a medium that creates and curates, the usual safety mechanisms disappear. With gatekeepers (editors, publishers, network executives) you could argue with them. They had taste, they had skin in the game and if they made bad decisions, their reputation suffered. You could then reliably wait for someone better to take their place.

With an algorithm that creates and curates, you have a system with no taste, no judgment and worse, no accountability. It has no stake in the outcome, it just optimises endlessly toward engagement, which may have nothing to do with truth, wisdom, or human flourishing. This is categorically different from radio or television. It's not just a new medium, but a new kind of medium.

The Tension

So we have a genuine intellectual dispute.

One camp says: McLuhan was right, the medium is the message, AI is just the latest iteration. It will reshape us the way television did, but that's how progress works. The form matters more than content, understand the environment and you understand the effect.

The other camp says: McLuhan didn't anticipate this, yes, the medium shapes us, but when the medium itself is generating the content, you've crossed into something new. It's not just a channel anymore, it's an actor that is actively participating in meaning-making. The old framework breaks.

What We Don't Know

This is genuinely unsettled.

We don't know yet whether McLuhan's framework is sufficient to explain what AI does. We don't know whether the distinction between a medium that distributes and a medium that creates makes the difference people fear. We don't know what happens to culture when content is infinitely variable and optimised for engagement.

We won't know for years, probably not until the effects are already woven into the fabric of how we think.What we do know is this: people who are frightened by AI aren't being irrational, they're responding to something real. Whether that something is adequately explained by "the medium is the message" or requires new theoretical frameworks entirely, we don't yet know.

That uncertainty is probably the most honest thing we can say about it.

What I Know From Making Things

Here's what tells me something real is at stake, the dissonance.

The pushback against "AI slop", the fact that people can taste the difference between something made by a human and something made by an algorithm even when they can't quite articulate why. That tension exists because we know something, intuitively, that the theoretical frameworks haven't caught up to: those gatekeepers are vital. Not gatekeepers who were always right, but gatekeepers who were human; with taste, judgment, skin in the game and fallibility.

Everything that is ever created comes at a human cost. Time, thought, suffering. Even this business(like many) was born out of personal reasons, not financial ones. The friction isn't a bug, it's proof that someone believed in it enough to spend the resources, that something mattered enough to take a risk on.

When we lose this essence of creation (that making is what humans are for) we feel it, I think we really feel it and we don't have words for it yet.

Maybe we need a word. Not "fear of AI" but something more precise, something that captures the specific anxiety of watching the mechanisms by which humans create and filter the world get replaced by something that has no understanding of why any of it matters. A word for the feeling of discovering/creating an entirely new class of intelligence and letting them generate everything we consume while we sit back and watch, never quite sure if they're teaching us or brainwashing us (Wall-E?)

Until we have that word, we're stuck trying to explain something new with old language, and that, might be the realest problem of all.

Designer, strategist and the person who answers the phone at Pretty Decent.

More about us
All insights

We Will Miss the ChatGPT Flyer

People are properly annoyed about AI posters made by small businesses. For thirty years the alternative was Comic Sans on a sheet of A4, and nobody minded that.

We Outgrew Ours Too

We spend most of our time telling businesses they've outgrown how they look. It's a strange feeling when it's your turn.

Nobody Decides to Go Off-Brand

Every brand drifts a little each time somebody needs a post by four o'clock, and AI has made four o'clock come round a lot more often.